Similarly, for VoA25, how many class/spec combos are there out there? I make it 21 with a mental count. You could stack a raid to minimise wasted loot for everyone.

Might be hard to fill the slots perfectly, but I reckon a lot of people would come out of the woodwork for something clever and/or fun like that.

Reset day today, maybe I’ll give it a shot this evening.

Doesn’t work so well for OS, of course.

In my humble opinion, you guys are making too much of a big deal about something so little. I hate ninjas, I hate when people start a raid while secretly planning to master loot some rare drop to themselves. At least this guy avoided doing that. Also one could say: “he should have said so, he should have been honest and clear about it”, but then, look at all the comments on this post.

In other words, he didn’t save anyone to his raid, he didn’t ninja loot the drop and the rogues who were left out had the choice to join another raid or start their own raid, in short: he didn’t interfere with the ability of the other rogues to get their loot that week. Morally gray? yes, but it could have been and I have seen worse.

so I will not cast stones on him becasue in the end, I might not go that far myself, but I have enough selfishness in me to reject a perfectly good candidade to ensure that I get the loot I came for. guilty. I’d be nice and upfront about it, but I’d do it.

The other day I joined a 25OS that a druid tank was running. At the end he gave out all the loot skipping over the druid token then after the satchel was given out, gave himself the token, dropped group, logged out and dropped vent…yes we were in his guild’s vent for a +1 attempt. I was soo ticked as I had 2 of my druid healers in my guild on that run and both got screwed. I proceeded to put him on my friends list and look out for future dealings. 2 days ago I saw him trying to put a 25 man naxx pug together and everytime he spammed his invites, I spammed that he ninja’d the token in OS and could not be trusted. So many ppl were giving me grief cause I was telling ppl about it. I was perplexed that ppl were telling me to quite crying and so forth when I was just trying to serve the pug community with a nice warning.

So now I only run my own pugs or guild runs. I’m not sure what drove me more nuts, the ninja or ppl who don’t care that ppl ninja.

No, you’re not the only person who thinks this kind of behaviour deserves an ass kicking.

This would be one of those times I “accidentally” misdirect to a guy… by accident!

I swear!

My only real comment here, and this is on behalf of my current guild, we are brand new. Yes I am an officer. But the incident where a person complained to me was when I was in a different guild (Fatal Error I believe, it was long ago), and it was about the amount of DPS a rogue was putting out. It was so low it basically made the run they were in impossible. Yes, he shouldn’t have been in there, but it’s not like he is going to get kicked out of the guild, as the person clearly wanted me to do.

Don’t think poorly of my current guild because of my comment is what I mean to say. I have a feeling that my current GM is more like you than me, as he has refused to invite several people we both know because of past actions such as ninjaing frozen orbs, and complaining non-stop on vent about never getting drops in Naxx. And I will uphold his standard, and, since we have had this conversation, I’ll mention it to him if I intend to do any runs where I may be farming something specific. Ask him if it would bother him if one of his officers did such a thing as take clothies on a farm trip for leather items.